I happen to like the Trop. Ray and his Dad have always been real nice to me. They have always taken time to answer questions, give a tour, and assist with tank problems. When I purchased a mate for my clownfish, the pair didn't work out. Ray took the clownfish back, and traded me for a big blue xenia rock. And that was two weeks later, after I couldn't make my female clownfish take to the new guy! ALL of the animals I have bought there have all been healthy. I have never had a problem with any fish, clams or coral. Prices, well... good stuff isn't cheap. I would rather pay more for healthy animals, than spend less, and have it die. I am rather new to MR, and I don't understand why anyone wouldn't like the Trop. As for where their stock comes from, well sure I would like to buy propagated animals. However, the demand in this hobby is quite large. It does seem like it would be difficult for ANYONE to grow enough coral, fish and clams to keep up with the demand.